Ángel J. Valencia
Ángel J. Valencia is a Senior Counsel at the Liberty Justice Center, where he litigates to defend individual liberties and challenge government overreach.
Home > Weiss v. Chicago Teachers Union
The Liberty Justice Center’s lawsuit achieved an important victory for Chicago Teachers Union members: CTU has now posted its complete financial audits on its member portal. But because CTU continues to deny that it must publish the complete audits each year, LJC is appealing to ensure that members do not have to file a new lawsuit every time CTU decides to withhold them.
When LJC filed this case in October 2024, CTU had not published the required annual audits since 2020. During the litigation, CTU offered shifting and contradictory accounts of those missing audits. CTU initially maintained that the audits had been completed. It later acknowledged that they were not complete, before ultimately stating that they had been completed in December 2025—more than a year after the lawsuit was filed.
The litigation thus revealed that CTU had told members and federal regulators that completed audits existed when, according to CTU’s later litigation position, they did not. Only after the lawsuit, a congressional investigation, and scrutiny from the U.S. Department of Labor did CTU post the complete audits on its member portal.
On September 11, 2026, the Circuit Court of Cook County granted summary judgment to CTU. The court deferred to CTU President Stacy Davis Gates’s interpretation that the bylaws permit CTU to publish only condensed summary pages while making the complete audits available for in-person inspection.
LJC will appeal that ruling. Although the complete audits are currently available on CTU’s portal, CTU has not agreed that it must keep them there or publish complete audits in future years. Under the trial court’s ruling, CTU could return to publishing only selected summaries, forcing members to begin the same fight again.
CTU members should not have to sue their union every year to obtain basic financial information. LJC’s appeal will seek to establish that CTU must honor its annual commitment to its members by publishing the complete audits consistently—not merely when litigation and outside scrutiny force it to do so.
On October 8, 2024 the Liberty Justice Center filed a lawsuit on behalf of Chicago Teachers Union (CTU) members, demanding that CTU produce an audit after failing to do so for four years.
Under CTU’s Constitution and Bylaws, Article VI, Section 1(d), the union is required to “furnish an audited report of the Union which shall be printed in the Union’s publication.” However, CTU has failed to meet this obligation since it published an audit only covering the first half of 2019.
“CTU members deserve to know where their money is going. After four years of silence, it’s time for transparency,” said plaintiff Phillip Weiss, who has been a CTU member since 1998. “This lawsuit isn’t just about us—it’s about the more than 25,000 educators across Chicago who rely on the union to uphold its commitments.”
The Liberty Justice Center previously sent a demand letter to the union on behalf of several anonymous CTU members, offering the opportunity to comply and avoid litigation. A week after receiving the letter, CTU’s lawyers requested the identity of the plaintiffs, purportedly to confirm their union membership.
Instead, the union used this information to launch into intimidation tactics to suppress dissent and distract from the core issue: its failure to provide financial transparency to members. On October 8, CTU President Stacy Davis Gates attempted to publicly shame the plaintiffs on a member-wide call by singling them out by name and invoking “Project 2025” to falsely frame their request for transparency as part of a “right-wing” effort.
After CTU failed to provide the missing audits by the letter’s deadline, the Liberty Justice Center filed the lawsuit to compel the audits’ release.
Weiss v. Chicago Teachers Union was filed in the Circuit Court of Cook County on October 8, 2024. The Liberty Justice Center is representing the members pro bono.
A copy of the Liberty Justice Center’s demand letter is available here.
stop public union corruption and show us the audit–it’s the law!
Ángel J. Valencia is a Senior Counsel at the Liberty Justice Center, where he litigates to defend individual liberties and challenge government overreach.
James McQuaid is the Managing Staff Attorney at Liberty Justice Center where he assists in cases to protect the rights to free speech, economic liberty, private property, and other Constitutional rights in courts across the country.
By The Editorial Board | Aug. 23, 2026 (Wall Street Journal Opinions) It accuses a think tank of defamation. Yeah, that will help the children. The Chicago Teachers Union is deeply unpopular, but rather than engage in soul-searching, it has taken a page from Donald Trump and filed a defamation...
By The Editorial Board | August 19, 2026 (Chicago Tribune) To be successful in politics, you need to attract allies and build coalitions. That’s basic stuff. The Chicago Teachers Union long ago refashioned itself as a political power player and at its peak in 2023 managed to get one of...
Sara Albrecht | February 20, 2026 (Crain’s Chicago Business) Chicago Teachers Union leaders would like the public to believe that recent federal scrutiny of their finances is part of a right-wing conspiracy — an attack on educators, students, and social justice itself. That framing may be effective rally rhetoric. It...
By: Tahman Bradley and Ethan Illers | November 25, 2025 CHICAGO (WGN-TV) – The Chicago Teachers Union is at the center of a Capitol Hill probe and is now cooperating with a Congressional inquiry into its finances regarding whether the CTU has been keeping financial audits from members. The Republican-controlled...
Author: Maggie Little (Read Lion)—A judge has allowed a lawsuit against the Chicago Teachers Union to move forward, as the union’s own members have been suing to demand financial transparency. The lawsuit stems from the union’s refusal to release its audits for five years, despite its bylaws requiring it to...
Author: Chris Coffey (Illinois Policy)—The Chicago Teachers Union suffered a defeat last week when a judge denied its request to dismiss a case filed against it demanding the release of audits its own rules mandate. In Weiss v. Chicago Teachers Union, several CTU members are challenging the union’s failure to...
(Off the Press)—The politically powerful Chicago Teachers Union can’t escape a lawsuit accusing them of violating their members’ rights by refusing to release years’ worth of financial audits, allegedly in breach of their own governing rules. On May 14, a Cook County judge rejected the CTU’s bid to dismiss the...
(Legal Newsline)—In a recent legal development, Judge David B. Atkins of the Circuit Court of Cook County has ruled in favor of the Liberty Justice Center in the case of Weiss v. Chicago Teachers Union (CTU). The court denied CTU’s motion to dismiss the case, marking a significant step for...