Liberty Justice Center Sues Montana Over Restrictions on Political Speech and Association

November 18, 2026

Lawsuit shows how I-194 reaches across state lines, cuts off PAC funding and threatens political service providers

HELENA, Mont. | Nov. 18, 2026 — The Liberty Justice Center (LJC) filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of four organizations challenging Montana’s Initiative 194 (I-194), a law that restricts their ability to speak about elections, support political advocacy and work together to advance their views.

LJC’s lawsuit, Young Americans for Liberty, Inc. v. Knudsen, et al., challenges I-194, which Montana voters approved on November 3, 2026. The measure declares that “political spending power” is not among the powers Montana grants to “artificial persons,” including corporations, nonprofit organizations, limited liability companies and certain other entities.

Scheduled to take effect on January 1, 2027, I-194 prohibits covered entities from spending money or “anything of value” to support or oppose candidates, political parties, political committees or ballot questions, except as provided by law for political committees. An organization that engages in prohibited spending forfeits its Montana-conferred charter privileges, including limited liability. The law also declares prohibited transactions void.

LJC’s lawsuit claims that I-194 restricts political speech and association, both on their face and as applied to the plaintiffs. It also argues that the law is unconstitutionally overbroad because it reaches a substantial amount of protected expression, including issue advocacy and ordinary business activities that support political communication.

The case brings together Montana and out-of-state plaintiffs: Young Americans for Liberty is a Virginia nonprofit corporation, PAC Management Services is a Delaware limited liability company and Make Liberty Win is a federal hybrid political action committee. I-194 expressly reaches organizations formed in other states. These plaintiffs show how the law threatens political participation across state lines, including a nonprofit’s funding relationship with a PAC and the ordinary business services that support political advocacy.

Young Americans for Liberty supports Make Liberty Win, a political action committee that reaches Montana voters through canvassing, direct mail and other political communications. According to the complaint, Young Americans for Liberty provides more than 90 percent of the funding Make Liberty Win expends. I-194 prohibits the contributions from Young Americans for Liberty that support Make Liberty Win’s Montana advocacy. Both organizations would be forced to end that funding relationship for Montana operations once the law takes effect.

The Montana Mining Association represents mining companies, small miners and allied trade members. It advocates for its members by speaking about candidates and ballot measures affecting the industry. I-194 would force the association to stop using its resources to support or oppose election outcomes.

PAC Management Services LLC provides compliance, treasury, contribution-processing and other services to political organizations and donors. The company’s ordinary business activities would fall within I-194’s restrictions, forcing it to cease its Montana operations to avoid sanctions.

“This case is not about protecting big business. It’s about protecting the freedom of individuals to form groups to speak and work together on issues that matter,” said Ryan Morrison, senior counsel at the Liberty Justice Center. “We’re asking the court to stop this law before it forces our clients to give up those rights.”

The lawsuit names Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen and Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen in their official capacities. It seeks a declaration that I-194 is unconstitutional and preliminary and permanent injunctions preventing its enforcement.

Young Americans for Liberty, Inc. v. Knudsen, et al. was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana, Helena Division, on November 16, 2026. Case filings are available on the Liberty Justice Center’s case page.

media requests

For more information or to schedule an interview, please contact us.

visit our substack

Read the latest from the Liberty Justice Center on our Substack site.