our Case

Young Americans for Liberty, Inc. v. Knudsen, et al.

Liberty Justice Center is defending four organizations against a Montana law that restricts political speech, cuts off advocacy funding and threatens the businesses that help people participate in elections.

About Young Americans for Liberty, Inc. v. Knudsen, et al.

Four organizations. Different roles. The same threat to political speech.

Make Liberty Win wants to continue reaching voters through canvassing, direct mail, phone banks and other political communications, with support from its contributors.

Young Americans for Liberty wants to continue supporting Make Liberty Win’s advocacy in Montana.

The Montana Mining Association wants to continue speaking for its members about candidates and ballot measures that affect Montana’s mining industry.

PAC Management Services LLC wants to continue providing compliance, treasury, contribution-processing and other services to political organizations and donors in Montana.

All four are challenging Initiative 194 (I-194), a measure approved by Montana voters on November 3, 2026, that threatens those activities when it takes effect on January 1, 2027.

The case brings together Montana and out-of-state plaintiffs: Young Americans for Liberty is a Virginia nonprofit corporation, PAC Management Services is a Delaware limited liability company and Make Liberty Win is a federal hybrid political action committee. I-194 expressly reaches organizations formed in other states. These plaintiffs show how the law threatens political participation across state lines, including a nonprofit’s funding relationship with a PAC and the ordinary business services that support political advocacy.

The right to speak does not depend on how an organization is formed.

I-194 declares that “political spending power” is not among the powers Montana grants to “artificial persons,” including corporations, nonprofit organizations, limited liability companies and certain other entities. Except as provided by law for political committees, it bars covered organizations from spending money or anything of value to support or oppose candidates, political parties, political committees or ballot questions.

The consequences go beyond a spending restriction. A covered organization that engages in prohibited spending forfeits its Montana-conferred charter privileges, including limited liability. The law also declares prohibited transactions void.

These restrictions force organizations to choose between exercising their First Amendment rights and retaining legal protections available under state law.

An exemption for political committees does not protect the relationships that make their advocacy possible.

Although I-194 exempts the lawful activities of political committees, it cuts off contributions from organizations such as Young Americans for Liberty, which provides more than 90 percent of the funding Make Liberty Win expends. The law would therefore burden both organizations’ ability to work together on Montana advocacy.

The Montana Mining Association would have to stop using its resources to support or oppose candidates and ballot measures. PAC Management Services would have to stop its Montana business operations to avoid sanctions for providing services that help others participate in elections.

The First Amendment protects political speech and the freedom to work together.

Liberty Justice Center’s lawsuit names Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen and Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen in their official capacities and challenges I-194 under the First and Fourteenth Amendments:

  1. Freedom of speech: Montana cannot restrict protected political expression based on an organization’s legal identity or condition state-conferred legal protections on surrendering First Amendment rights.
  2. Freedom of association: I-194 unconstitutionally interferes with organizations’ ability to work with contributors, political committees and service providers to advance shared political goals.
  3. Overbreadth: The law reaches protected expression, including issue advocacy and ordinary business activities that support political communication.

Montana cannot make silence the price of doing business or advocating together.

The lawsuit seeks a declaration that I-194 is unconstitutional and preliminary and permanent injunctions preventing its enforcement. The requested preliminary relief would protect the organizations’ speech and association while the case proceeds.

Young Americans for Liberty, Inc. v. Knudsen, et al. was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana, Helena Division, on November 16, 2026.

media requests

To schedule an interview about this case, please contact us.

Case Details

CASE NAME

Young Americans for Liberty, Inc. v. Knudsen, et al.

Filed

November 16, 2026

Court

U.S. District Court for the District of Montana, Helena Division

Status

Pending

Liberty Justice Center Attorneys

Ryan Morrison

Ryan joined the Liberty Justice Center as Senior Counsel in May 2025 to protect the right of free speech, defend the right to keep and bear arms, and stop government overreach.