Gutterman v. Indiana University - Liberty Justice Center

Gutterman v. Indiana University

In the fall of 2018, Cameron Gutterman, Dale Nelson, Hunter Johnson and Brian Hiltunen were Indiana University Bloomington freshmen who decided to check out Greek life. They pledged Beta Theta Pi fraternity, an affiliation they continue to enjoy today as juniors who live in the fraternity house on campus.

Also in the fall of 2018, Indiana University launched against Beta Theta Pi a hazing investigation, imposing sanctions against the fraternity at its conclusion.

No wrongdoing ever was alleged against Gutterman, Nelson, Johnson or Hiltunen. Yet university officials searched their student ID card swipe data as part of their investigation. Without requesting or gaining pre-compliance, they reviewed records detailing the students’ comings and goings around campus, violating the students’ civil rights.

“Students don’t give up their constitutional rights just because they live in state university dormitories,” said Jeffrey Schwab, senior attorney at the Liberty Justice Center. “If state universities are going to collect data on student movements in and out of college buildings and dorm rooms, then they must take steps to protect that data and establish a process before accessing it to protect their students’ privacy.”

Best known for its landmark Janus v. AFSCME victory in the U.S. Supreme Court, the Liberty Justice Center has filed a federal lawsuit, Gutterman v. Indiana University, on the students’ behalf against IU and university President Michael McRobbie. The complaint alleges Fourth and 14th Amendment violations as well as breach of the contract existing between university and student.

Background

The complaint was filed Oct 29, 2020, in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana in Indianapolis by the Liberty Justice Center on the students’ behalf against IU and university President Michael McRobbie. The complaint alleges Fourth and 14th Amendment violations as well as breach of the contract existing between university and student.

Briefs

Complaint 10/29/2020

Exhibit A 11/02/2020

Press Release 10/29/2020

Exhibit A 02/16/2021

Exhibit B 02/16/2021

Exhibit C 02/16/2021

Motion to Dismiss 02/16/2021

Memo of Motion to Dismiss 02/16/2021

Order Regarding Protective Orders 02/26/2021

Opposition to Defendants' MTD 03/09/2021

Defendants' Preliminary Witness and Exhibit Lists 03/17/2021

MTD Reply 03/23/2021

Final Judgment 09/01/2021

Order 09/01/2021

Notice of Appeal 09/27/2021

Notice of Docketing 09/28/2021

Appellants' Brief and Short Appendix 11/08/2021

Appellees' Brief 12/08/2021

Reply Brief 01/13/2022

Motion to Dismiss 06/06/2022

Order 06/08/2022

Response 06/20/2022

Order Dismissing as Moot 06/27/2022

Want to Learn More?

You might Also like

State of the Unions – Chicago Magazine

This article by Edward Robert McClelland was published October 24, 2022 on chicagomag.com. As other Midwestern states restrict labor’s power, an amendment on the Illinois ballot would further protect it here. Bruce Rauner hated unions. But as a Republican governor with a Democratic legislature, he...