Timothy R. Snowball
Tim Snowball serves as Senior Counsel at Liberty Justice Center, where he fights to keep government power in check while protecting the individual constitutional rights of Americans.
Home > Duquette v. State of Vermont
Five families. Different educational needs. The same barrier: their home addresses.
Allison Duquette wants her son to attend a public school with stronger academics.
Amia Cervantes wants her son to learn alongside his teammates in a stable school environment.
Nichole Kruger wants her four children to attend nearby public schools that better meet their academic needs.
Theresa McDonough wants coursework that challenges her gifted daughter without separating her from children her own age.
Chrissy Haskins wants her son to keep receiving the special education support that is helping him thrive.
Vermont already has a program that helps eligible families access schools that fit their children’s needs. These five families are challenging the rule that excludes them from this opportunity.
This case is not about which schools can receive town tuitioning—it’s about the families excluded from it.
Vermont’s town tuitioning program has existed since 1869 and allows eligible families to use public education funding to attend other public schools or approved independent schools. But state law excludes the families represented by the Liberty Justice Center because their home districts operate public schools, even when those schools do not adequately meet their children’s needs.
The complaint cites research showing that students with access to greater educational opportunity fare better than their peers with fewer educational options. The complaint examines academic performance, preparation for college, access to specialized services, extracurricular activities and the quality of school facilities.
Because of where they live, these families are denied opportunities available to other Vermont families. To access schools that better meet their children’s needs, they must pay tuition themselves or move.
These families just want the same educational opportunity as their neighbors.
Three of the five plaintiff families want to use the town tuitioning system to choose another public school. Allison would choose public schooling in Colchester. Amia would choose public schooling in Barre. Nichole would choose public schools in Colchester or South Burlington.
Their experiences underscore the central issue: LJC argues that providing some families access to educational opportunity while denying that same benefit to others based on nothing more than school district boundaries violates the Vermont Constitution.
Vermont’s Constitution protects educational opportunity for all Vermonters.
The Liberty Justice Center filed this lawsuit against the State of Vermont and Secretary of Education Zoie Saunders, in her official capacity, under two provisions of the Vermont Constitution:
According to the complaint, the differences in academic offerings, special education support, facilities and extracurricular opportunities leave the children of these families without substantially equal opportunities to learn. Denying them town tuitioning prevents them from accessing alternatives.
A child’s educational needs do not stop at a school district line.
The lawsuit seeks a declaration that the exclusion violates the Vermont Constitution and a permanent injunction preventing the state from enforcing it against these families or other affected families.
Duquette v. State of Vermont was filed in the Vermont Superior Court, Civil Division, on November 16, 2026.
Tim Snowball serves as Senior Counsel at Liberty Justice Center, where he fights to keep government power in check while protecting the individual constitutional rights of Americans.
Tim Kilcullen serves as a staff attorney at the Liberty Justice Center. He has a deep passion for protecting Americans’ fundamental liberties, particularly their right to free speech and a free press.
Parents of school-age children. Vermont citizens. Equal education opportunity advocates.
These five families are raising children with different strengths, challenges and ambitions. What brings them together is a shared request: access to the same town tuitioning opportunity Vermont already provides to other families. They are challenging the state’s exclusion of families whose districts operate their own schools—a restriction that denies them access based on where they live.
Milton mother. Former school board member. Seeking a return to public school.
When Allison Duquette became concerned about academic standards and the learning environment in the Milton Town School District, she worked to change them. She ran for—and won—a seat on the local school board, where she advocated for educational reform.
Eventually, Allison withdrew her eleven-year-old son and began homeschooling him. That decision has imposed a substantial personal and financial burden on her family.
Allison would prefer her son to attend school with his peers. She wants him to attend public school in neighboring Colchester.
Allison is not asking for town tuitioning to leave public education. She wants to use it to return her son to a public-school classroom that better meets his needs.
Waltham mother of two. Seeking a challenge without sacrificing community.
Theresa McDonough’s second-grade daughter is academically gifted, but her public school does not offer accelerated coursework to meet her needs.
The school offered to let her daughter skip a grade, but Theresa does not want her daughter to have to adapt socially to children older than her simply to receive appropriately challenging work.
Theresa enrolled both of her children at Champlain Valley Christian School, taking on the expense herself. She would use town tuitioning if her family were eligible, even if that meant choosing a different school.
Theresa wants her children to have access to an education that meets their needs—not a choice between academic challenge and age-appropriate peers.
Northfield mother. Supporting her son’s education, safety and sense of belonging.
Amia Cervantes’ son is fourteen years old. She wants him to spend his school days learning—not being pulled from class to give witness testimony on the fights between other students.
After witnessing traumatizing school altercations and fights at his assigned school, her son has been repeatedly asked to write witness reports. The pressure brought on by staff to accuse his peers of misdeeds has brought him to tears.
Amia’s son also wants to participate in football, lacrosse and wrestling—sports his assigned school does not offer. Amia has been paying out of pocket for him to participate in football and wrestling in neighboring Barre.
She wants him to attend public school in Barre, too, so he can learn alongside his teammates in a stable environment where he is free to learn without inappropriate distractions.
Amia is seeking access to another public school, where her son could build his education and his school community in the same place.
Jamaica mother. Providing her son with programs that best support him.
Chrissy Haskins’s third-grade son has special education needs and a natural aptitude for mathematics.
Chrissy struggled to secure an individualized education plan (IEP) for him, and his public school could not provide the individualized services he needed. It also offered no accelerated math program.
Chrissy enrolled him in private school at Mountain School at Winhall at substantial personal expense, because the school can better accommodate his need for an individualized education plan and support his aptitude for mathematics.
If the Haskins family lived just ten miles west, the complaint alleges, her son would qualify for town tuitioning at the same school.
Chrissy wants her son’s educational opportunity to depend on his needs—not on his leaving the land where his family has lived for generations.
Milton mother of four school-age children. Seeking stronger public-school opportunities.
Nichole Kruger is raising four school-age children in Milton, each with years of learning ahead.
Milton students’ academic results lag behind those in nearby Colchester and South Burlington. Nichole wants her children to have access to those neighboring public schools.
Her family cannot use town tuitioning to access those schools because they live in Milton, a district that operates its own schools.
Nichole wants what tuitioning-eligible families already have: the ability to use public education funding at another school—including another public school—that better serves her children.
Together, these parents are asking Vermont to give their children access to an educational opportunity other families already enjoy. Their case challenges the exclusion under the Education Clause and Common Benefits Clause of the Vermont Constitution. It is about which children are allowed to benefit—not about choosing public schools over private schools, or private schools over public schools.
“We aren’t asking the state to fund our children going to the fanciest private school in the state,” says Allison Duquette. “We are simply asking for the same benefits as other families in Vermont—a benefit we are owed under the state constitution.”