Vermont Business Magazine

Liberty Justice Center sues Vermont alleging unequal access to educational opportunity

November 18, 2026

Vermont Business Magazine | November 17, 2026

(Vermont Business Magazine)

 Liberty Justice Center’s PARENTS Initiative, a national organization, filed a lawsuit yesterday on behalf of five Vermont families challenging the state’s statutory Exclusion Rule that denies them access to equal educational opportunity based on nothing more than their home addresses.

The lawsuit, Duquette v. State of Vermont, et al., challenges the exclusion of families from a state program that allows families without a public school in their district to use education funding at public schools or approved independent schools throughout the state. The complaint alleges that this unequal access to educational opportunity violates the Education Clause and Common Benefits Clause of the Vermont Constitution.

For the families bringing the case, the question is not about which schools can participate in town tuitioning. It is about which children are allowed to benefit—and the answer should be all of them.

As alleged in the complaint based on numerous academic studies and hard data, students with access to great educational opportunity fare better than their peers who are locked into failing schools. This is true in four concrete areas: academic performance, preparation for college, access to special services, and extracurriculars and quality of facilities.

The plaintiffs’ stories demonstrate the need for equal educational opportunities for all Vermont families.

Allison Duquette is homeschooling her son after becoming concerned about academic standards and the learning environment in the Milton Town School District. She would prefer to send her son to public school in neighboring Colchester. Nichole Kruger, also of Milton, wants her four school-age children to attend public schools in Colchester or South Burlington. Amia Cervantes wants her son to attend public school in neighboring Barre, where he already participates in football and wrestling at her expense.

According to the complaint, all three families are denied equal educational opportunity for no other reason than where they happen to live.

“These families are asking for access to an educational opportunity Vermont already provides to their fellow Vermonters,” said Timothy R. Snowball, senior counsel for the PARENTS Initiative. “They simply want to send their children to schools that offer programs and educational support that better meet their children’s needs. This case is about who gets access—not about choosing public schools over private schools, or private schools over public schools.”

The other two families have taken on private-school tuition to meet needs they say their assigned public schools could not address.

Theresa McDonough of Waltham enrolled her children at Champlain Valley Christian School after finding that her academically gifted daughter needed more challenging coursework. Christina Haskins of Jamaica enrolled her son at the Mountain School at Winhall, where they can better accommodate his need for an individualized education plan and support his aptitude for mathematics. If the Haskins family lived just ten miles west, the complaint alleges, her son would qualify for town tuitioning at that very same school.

The lawsuit brings two related claims under Vermont’s Constitution. Under the Education Clause, read together with the Common Benefits Clause, PARENTS argues that the state must ensure substantial equality of educational opportunity throughout Vermont. Under the Common Benefits Clause, they challenge the state’s decision to make town tuitioning available to some families while excluding others based on their school district of residence.

The lawsuit seeks a declaration that the challenged exclusion is unconstitutional and a permanent injunction preventing its enforcement against the plaintiffs and other affected families.

Duquette v. State of Vermont, et al. was filed in the Vermont Superior Court, Civil Division, on November 16, 2026. Case filings are available on Liberty Justice Center’s case page.